Navigating The Efficient Frontier: Is A Renovation Right For You?

by: Allegra Kochman | 15th May 2024 | Process & Planning, Process, Strategy | No Comments
Graph depicting efficient frontier with and without real estate return trends over time.

In this article, we explore key considerations for deciding whether to invest in a major home renovation and emphasize the importance of self-knowledge in order to help you make an informed decision.

Identifying Your Core Values

Before embarking on a renovation journey, it’s crucial to understand what truly matters to you. Is it the investment? The functional experience of living in and using your home? Or the aesthetic appeal of an open, well-lit, visually striking space that can accommodate various lifestyles and needs? Each of these will have different investments and returns.

Your core values play a crucial role in determining your approach to renovation budgeting. At AKA, we’ve identified two distinct budget personalities: “Budget-Oriented” and “Value-Oriented.” Recognizing which aligns with your values will help ensure a successful and satisfying renovation experience. Read our companion article and take our personality quiz, “What is Your Renovation Budget Personality?

Reflecting on your core values will guide you in making choices that align with your priorities, ensuring that the renovated space resonates with your authentic self.

Keep Up With Trends To Build Substance

It is wise to consider whether current fashions and popular design styles align with your plans. The market influences resale value and shapes the overall appeal of your home for potential buyers. Features that are popular now help you sell to the average consumer in the short term. Long-term, value-oriented features stay relevant and are future necessities worth adding to a home. Interpreting which trends will stay relevant will help your apartment maintain value.

Current long-term value-oriented trends include: 

  • Cooking with electricity instead of gas, 
  • Heated toilets, 
  • Heated floors, 
  • Layered lighting.

The Blueprint for Timeless Appeal

There are architectural elements that transcend time. Light, views, and space are core characteristics of great architecture. Maximize light, expand sightlines, open your space, and create more storage. All of these are unlikely to go out of style! Strike a balance by incorporating relevant popular features that you will enjoy and fundamental architectural characteristics to create a home that seamlessly blends your personal style and goals with long-lasting value.

6 Plans of the same apartment with yellow color fields in specific spiky shapes on the plan starting at the west and penetrating into the apartment based on wall placement.
These six plans generate the data that allows us to analyze sunlight penetration before and after a gut renovation at an AKA-designed apartment, The Grand Four. Following the renovation, there’s a notable enhancement in sunlight exposure: a 37% increase during summer, a 42% boost in daylight during Spring and Fall, and a remarkable 58% increase in sunlight during winter, lending an ambiance reminiscent of Miami.

Resale Value: Short-term or Long-term

When assessing the resale value of your renovated home, consider your potential timeline for selling. If you plan to sell shortly after the renovation, prioritize broad appeal and marketability. Focus on updates that offer a strong return on investment and cater to the preferences of most buyers in your local market. This is a less customized design that focuses on specific value-creating upgrades.

  • Renovating bathrooms
  • Renovating kitchens
  • Floor refinishing
  • Painting
  • New Windows
Allegra stands by a window that fills the frame. The warm glow of sunset sits on the horizon across the Hudson River.

If you envision enjoying your renovated home for several years or even a decade, your personal enjoyment should take precedence. In this case, tailor the renovation to your unique lifestyle, prioritizing light, views, and the spaces that bring you daily joy and comfort. Is the experience of your home an intangible value that is important to you? This renovation will reflect more personal choices that will delight you. It will include redefining room boundaries, relocating and enlarging door openings, and custom cabinets that optimize storage.

  • Relocate and enlarge doorways
  • Change hinged doors to pocket doors
  • Shift interior walls to optimize useable space and sightlines
Before: A Foyer with doors to a Living Room, a Corridor, and a Dining Room arrayed around the perimeter; After: (same view) We pushed back the door to the entry corridor and allowed the door openings to the Living Room and the Dining Room to face each other.

The Rent Equivalent And Investment Value Consideration

Renovations represent a significant financial investment, and it’s important to weigh the costs against potential returns. Calculate the “rent equivalent” – the amount you would pay to rent a similar, newly renovated property. Compare this figure to the renovation costs and the projected increase in your home’s market value.

Additionally, consider the investment value of the difference between these amounts. Could that money potentially yield higher returns if invested elsewhere? Evaluate these factors objectively to ensure your renovation aligns with your long-term financial goals. Furthermore, consider the space you would be renting, is it sufficiently customized to your needs so that it feels like home?

Enjoying The Journey: Putting A Price On Happiness

While financial factors are important, it’s crucial not to underestimate the intangible benefits of personal satisfaction and happiness. A successful renovation can significantly enhance your living environment, fostering joy, comfort, and cherished memories. It’s important to recognize the emotional and psychological value of living in a space that truly reflects your personality and lifestyle. The pride and contentment that come from a well-planned renovation are invaluable.

Before: Viewed from an interior room with door openings, large windows are partially visible in the kitchen straight ahead and the living room on the right.. After: The wall straight ahead was removed to create an open-plan kitchen and dining room. The door opening on the right was enlarged to allow a full view of the living room window. Windows are now revealed in their entirety.

Striking The Perfect Balance

Self-knowledge is essential to navigating the efficient frontier of home renovations requires a delicate balance of personal preferences, market trends, financial considerations, and emotional fulfillment. It is important that you understand your priorities and limitations. For more insights, read our article “Make Peace With Your Home Renovation Budget in 2 Steps!.” Once you have this foundation, consult with the expertise of trusted professionals, such as architects and interior designers, to guide you through this intricate process.
Pro Tip: Be open and honest with yourself about your goals to set yourself on the path toward a successful renovation.

With your self-knowledge and your architect’s professional knowledge and creative vision, you can seamlessly merge your individual desires with practical considerations.  This will help your renovation journey culminate in a space that embodies your essence and meets your functional and financial objectives.

The efficient frontier is a dynamic path that evolves as your priorities shift. Embrace the journey, remain open to new perspectives, and trust your instincts to create a living space that genuinely reflects who you are and what you value most.

Allegra smiles at the photographer from behind an open laptop. The night-time reflection in the large window behind her mirrors her illuminated kitchen cabinets.

Moving Forward:

The maximum value of a home renovation lies in the intangible joy and satisfaction it brings to your daily life. Embrace this opportunity to craft a home that truly reflects your unique essence, one that will continue to inspire and delight you for years to come. Trust your instincts, seek expert guidance, and approach this endeavor with an open mind and a willingness to embrace new perspectives.


About Us:

Allegra Kochman

About the Author

Allegra Kochman

Allegra has a BA with Honors from Dartmouth College and a Master of Architecture from Columbia University. She aims to write straightforward and practical content for those who want to gut renovate their homes.

Did you find this article helpful?
Leave comments for us below

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Schedule Your Complimentary
20-Minute Discovery Call

TAKE THE FIRST STEP